UK Tribunal Orders Home Office to Stop Hiding Apple Encryption Notice
Security / news
UK Tribunal Orders Home Office to Stop Hiding Apple Encryption Notice
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal's Nov. 19 judgment confirms the order exists. What it requires of Apple stays sealed until a hearing expected in the first half of 2027.

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on November 19 that the UK Home Office can no longer refuse to confirm that it served Apple with a technical capability notice, the secret order that can require a company to change a product so officials can reach customer data. The ruling covers only the existence of the notice. Its contents remain sealed, and the tribunal has not decided whether the order is lawful.
The panel of Lady Carmichael, Mr Justice Chamberlain and Mr Justice Johnson published an open judgment, [2026] UKIPTrib 9, after a hearing on September 17, according to PPC Land's account of it. The judgment text itself was not fetched, so the quotations below come from that account and from Reclaim The Net and Reuters.

What the tribunal decided on November 19
The Home Office relied on its "neither confirm nor deny" policy. Its barrister, Neil Sheldon KC, argued that confirmation would "create a damaging precedent for future national security cases", per PPC Land. The Home Office witness Andrew Scurry said the policy "is only effective when it is maintained consistently", according to Reclaim The Net.
The tribunal found that officials had authorised briefings to The Times and the Financial Times, a "significant departure" from that policy. It wrote that "anyone with even a passing interest in this topic already knows" the notice exists, and called the government's claim that confirmation would help hostile actors "fanciful". The government "has not established that it would be damaging to national security" to reveal the notice, the judgment says.
The government's reply, reported by Reuters, was that Apple has helped police and intelligence agencies "for several years" and that the notice "simply requires that they maintain the ability to do so."
The timeline, and where the sources disagree
The accounts do not agree on when the second notice was issued. Reuters puts it in July 2025. PPC Land says an order was "reportedly" issued in September 2025. The judgment, as summarised, does not settle the point.
| Date | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Jan. 2025 | First notice, covering US and UK users' encrypted backups | Reuters |
| Feb. 2025 | Apple stops offering Advanced Data Protection to new UK users | Reclaim The Net |
| Aug. 19, 2025 | US Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard says the UK agreed to drop its demand | PPC Land |
| Jul. or Sep. 2025 | Second notice, limited to UK users | Reuters, PPC Land |
| Jul. 2026 | Apple files its second tribunal claim | PPC Land |
| Nov. 19, 2026 | Open judgment published | PPC Land |
What stays secret and what Apple argues
Advanced Data Protection is Apple's optional end-to-end encryption for iCloud. Apple says 10 categories of data are no longer end-to-end encrypted for new UK users, including iCloud Backup, Photos and Notes, per Reclaim The Net. Apple has not set a deadline for existing UK users to switch it off.
Apple's second claim, numbered IPT/26/191/CH, has five grounds. Two will be heard entirely in open court: whether the Home Office can issue warrants with effect outside the UK, and whether the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 can be used to regulate a company's security or privacy features. A fifth ground, whether Apple was treated differently from other technology companies, is likely to rely on evidence that cannot be made public, according to PPC Land.
Privacy International, Liberty, Ian Hosein and Ben Wizner brought a parallel claim, IPT/25/83-86/CH. Akiko Hart, director of Liberty, called the ruling a win for transparency, per Reuters.

What changes for UK users
The ruling does not order Apple to change anything. The notice is believed to concern iCloud data of British users, according to Reclaim The Net, and the judgment does not say what it requires. The practical consequence is procedural: much of the case can be argued in open court.
A December 2026 hearing date was agreed to be impractical. The parties are aiming for a substantive hearing in the first half of 2027. Other security coverage on the site includes the NSA network outage report and the NPCI Android sideloading analysis.
Sources
More in Security
- 01Windows Server 2028 Preview Hardens Server Core by Default in Build 29706, but NTLM Is Still OpenHundreds of settings are on from first boot, Microsoft warns Server 2025 workloads may break, and the 33 percent of servers still on 2019 are untouched.
- 02VicOne's 28 Robotics Zero-Days Come From a Sponsored Article With No CVE IDs and No Named ProjectsThe Tokyo security firm's count ran as paid content on IEEE Spectrum and The Robot Report. An independent March paper counted 38 flaws in three named consumer robots.
- 03Synology's Third Critical DSM Advisory in 62 Days Hits OAuth, and the Last Patch Does Not Cover ItCVE-2026-120382 scores 9.8 and needs no login. DSM 7.4 and 7.3 builds ending -2 and -6 fix it; 7.2 and 7.1 have none yet.
- 04Codex's Sandbox Uses Seatbelt, bubblewrap and MXC, and Lets Commands Read Broadly by DefaultOpenAI's Nov. 18 engineering post says writes are confined to the workspace and the network is off, while reads stay wide open.