Dettato's Audio-to-MIDI Claim Counts 20M Parameters, but Its Chain Totals 28.1M
Software / news
Dettato's Audio-to-MIDI Claim Counts 20M Parameters, but Its Chain Totals 28.1M
The Apache-2.0 transcriber scores 59.2 composite F1 on nine sets against MuScriptor's 45.1, though its author has not scored the four models as one chain.

The Hacker News title on Dettato, an open audio-to-MIDI transcriber, calls it "60x more efficient." The author's own page says "roughly 65x smaller than muscriptor", and the figure counts 20 million parameters out of a four-model chain that totals more.
KobiMusic LLC published the Dettato research page on Nov. 16. The GitHub README says code and weights are Apache-2.0, so commercial use is allowed. The repository had 164 stars and no open issues on Nov. 21.

What the 20M counts
The README says Dettato is "four models in a chain": a transcriber of 15.3 million parameters, an evidence repairer of 4.9 million, a grouper of 2.9 million and a drum model of 5.0 million. The benchmarked part, the transcriber plus drums, is 20.3 million. All four add up to 28.1 million by The Terminal's arithmetic, which puts MuScriptor's 1.3 billion at about 46 times larger, not 65.
The README concedes the gap in one sentence: "I have not scored the four models as one chain yet, the way this package runs them." The evidence repairer was measured alone at +0.30 composite, and the grouper on the author's own track benchmark.
| Stage | Parameters | Role |
|---|---|---|
| Transcriber | 15.3M | Finds the notes |
| Evidence repairer | 4.9M | Fixes notes using transcriber evidence |
| Grouper | 2.9M | Assigns notes to instrument tracks |
| Drum model | 5.0M | Writes the drums |
Scores on nine sets, and on Mirelo's three
On nine public benchmark sets, the README gives Dettato a composite F1 of 59.2, with a 95 percent interval of 57.9 to 60.6, against 45.1 for MuScriptor. F1 balances missed and false notes, and the composite is the mean of onset, frame, offset and drum scores. Eight of the sets come from the MuScriptor paper's Table 2, plus Slakh2100, and the author says he scored them with that paper's rules.
Mirelo's closed A2M v1.1 Pro reports only three sets, so the comparison there is narrower. All figures below are vendor-supplied, and Mirelo's own number is the one Mirelo published.
- Dettato60.8 F1
- Mirelo A2M v1.1 Pro56.1 F1
- MuScriptor 1.3B47.4 F1
- YourMT3+45.7 F1
Source: KobiMusic Dettato research page, Nov. 16, 2026 (author-supplied; Mirelo figure as published by Mirelo), accessed 2026-11-21
MuScriptor's own model card, from Mirelo and Kyutai, reports 60.4 onset F1 on a 372-track set of its own, against 32.5 for YourMT3+. Different test set, different numbers: the two cards cannot be compared with each other.
What the author says it gets wrong
The README says the weakest step is assigning notes to instrument tracks, and gives an example: "on jazz recordings a quarter of the saxophone notes can land in the piano track." The Hugging Face card adds that the range is the 88 piano keys, with at most two notes on one key at a time, and that output is performance MIDI, not quantised to a beat.
Audio goes in at 16 kHz, in 8-second windows that start 2 seconds apart. The card lists 6,175 downloads for the last month and 12 likes, and gives no memory or GPU figure; from_pretrained takes "cuda" or "cpu".
On licensing, MuScriptor's weights are CC BY-NC 4.0, gated behind a form, and "provided primarily for research purposes." Dettato's are Apache-2.0 with no form. The author says no copyrighted recordings were used for training and the training audio will not be released, a claim The Terminal could not check. Compare the framing in Nemotron 3.5 Bolt, where a name and a file size disagreed, or in Frostbite's 4.59x claim against an unnamed baseline.
The next number to watch is a score for the four models run as one chain, which the README says does not exist yet.
Sources
More in Software
- 01Brazil's Receita Federal Posts Tax Calculator Under MIT With 16 Open IssuesThe agency published three repositories on Nov. 16 for the new consumption taxes, and outside developers had filed bug reports against the first within days.
- 02OpenSRE Hits 13,884 Stars After Repositioning Toward CI/CD FailuresThe Apache-2.0 agent is labelled public alpha, ships a dated release almost every day, and sends analytics and crash reports unless users set an environment variable.
- 03Microsoft 365's 1,430-Minute Outage Traces to a July Windows ChangeMicrosoft's preliminary report blames a latent lock-contention defect, a Teams failover and 14 percent of gateway capacity already offline, and customers have until the end of December to claim service credits.
- 04Firecrawl's Alexandria Data Library Is Missing From Its 205,955-Star RepoThe AGPL-3.0 repository covers scraping and a self-hosted server, while the 550-provider data library and search run on Firecrawl Cloud.