European Court of Human Rights Bars Romanian Lawyer for Two Years Over AI Citations
A.I. / news
European Court of Human Rights Bars Romanian Lawyer for Two Years Over AI Citations
The Court's own database could have caught the errors, according to two Romanian outlets, and sources differ on the lawyer's pronoun.
The European Court of Human Rights has barred a Romanian lawyer from representing or assisting applicants for two years after finding that AI-drafted written observations cited cases that do not exist. The Court's President approved the exclusion on Nov. 13, and the Court published the decision on Nov. 18.
The lawyer was one of two representatives in an application the Court does not name. The sanction applies to that lawyer only. The Court does not name the lawyer either.
What the Chamber found
The Court's page lists three kinds of error in the observations. There were non-existent cases, fictitious paragraphs attributed to genuine judgments and decisions, and real case law that was irrelevant or contradicted the point it was cited for.
The lawyer acknowledged using AI tools to draft the text and called the problems "inaccuracies" and "citation errors." The Chamber described "a pattern of numerous, repeated, substantive errors rather than isolated citation mistakes," and found the conduct fell short of professional and ethical duties that the Court imposes and that Romanian law also contains.
Two Romanian outlets that read the full press release add detail the Court's web page omits. Stirile ProTV reports that some references were not checked at all, and that many errors could have been caught by a simple search of HUDOC, the Court's own case-law database. It also reports that the Chamber found the Court had to spend considerable time verifying the submissions and corresponding with the parties, which it counted as disrupting the administration of justice.
The rule and the sanction
Spotmedia reports that the exclusion rests on Article 44D of the Court's Rules, and that the Chamber found "exceptional circumstances" within that article. It also cites Romanian Law No. 51/1995 on the legal profession, the profession's statute, the Romanian code of ethics and the Court's own case law on the duty of diligence.
| Item | What was reported |
|---|---|
| Decision date | Nov. 13, 2026 |
| Announced | Nov. 18, 2026 |
| Sanction | Two years, one of two representatives |
| Rule | Article 44D of the Rules of Court |
Spotmedia and Stirile ProTV both say the decision does not stop the lawyer's right to represent applicants from being restored under Article 44D(3). Spotmedia names Court President Mattias Guyomar as the official who approved the exclusion. It says the Romanian government, the National Union of the Bars of Romania and the Bar of Iași were informed, along with the applicants. Stirile ProTV says the Bar of Iași, invited to comment, did not respond.
A discrepancy in the coverage
The Court's English page refers to the lawyer as "she." Spotmedia and Stirile ProTV, both Romanian outlets, write about the lawyer in the masculine. The sources do not settle it, so this report uses neither pronoun. A third Romanian report, from informat.ro, was blocked when the Terminal tried to open it.
What the sources leave out
No source identifies the AI system the lawyer used. The Court's page does not say how many of the citations were false. The Court's English page links English and Romanian press releases, and neither Romanian outlet gives a date on which the lawyer could ask for the exclusion to be lifted.
For another report on a claim made about AI output, see the Terminal's coverage of Anthropic's black hole result. For a different approach to checking AI behaviour before it reaches users, see Chrome's synthetic web for testing Auto Browse. This ruling is narrower: the body that imposed the penalty is the one whose case law was misquoted, and its own HUDOC database could have caught the errors.
Sources
More in A.I.
- 01OpenAI Says New Safeguards Cut Reasoning Extraction From 54.0% to 0.2%The figures are from OpenAI's own red-team evaluation, and the post names DeepSeek and Moonshot AI as distillers of U.S. models.
- 02Frostbite, an AI-Designed CPU, Claims 4.59x Efficiency Over an Unnamed BaselineArchitect Labs reports pre-silicon results from a 7 nm layout and has not said the chip has been fabricated.
- 03NVIDIA Nemotron 3.5 Bolt Is Called 4GB; Its 4-Bit File Is 6.18 GBThe Gemma 4 E4B derivative wins seven of eight benchmark rows against its base on NVIDIA's own harness, but loses five of eight to Qwen3.5 4B.
- 04Chrome Built a Fake Web to Test Auto Browse Against Prompt InjectionTwo Chrome AI Security engineers describe a gVisor sandbox that serves generated sites at real URLs, with injections chosen by a request header.